More nuclear power plants only increase
the size of the waste problem, the risks to the environment and
human population, and the threat of nuclear proliferation. Plants
continue to experience safety violations and missing spent fuel,
and the owners of aging plants are succeeding in getting 20 year
license renewals. On this page we will focus on the licensing
and safety issues of nuclear power plants, and present studies
and news articles that suggest alternatives.
October
16, 2006 Shundahai Network responds
to NRC Commissioner Dale Klein's comments about the future of
nuclear power in a Nebraska StatePaper.com article.
October 12,
2006 Shundahai Network joins
the dialogue with Dave Kraft from NEIS on mywebtimes.com in
the debate over whether the La Salle County Generating Station
(IL) should be re licensed for another 20 years.
March 14, 2006 -
Shundahai
Network publishes Op-ed in Salt Lake Tribune :
Eileen McCabe-Olsen and Pete Litster co-authored an op-ed on the
drawbacks of nuclear power. A longer, footnoted version is available
here.
June 2006 - update
Grassroots and Local Legislative
Resistance to the Nuclear Industry
Oyster Creek, Vermont Yankee, A landmark decision
was made in federal court at the beginning of June. A number of
groups including the San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace challenged
the environmental report that did not account for the threat of
terrorism, should spent fuel be stored on site. The court found
that this threat must
be assessed. There have been far-reaching effects to this
decision. Opponents of the re-licensing of Oyster
Creek in New Jersey, and the proposed PFS
dump in Utah both see this decision as a possible support
for their opposition. In May, a federal court dealt another set-back
to states wanting to have control over the shipping of nuclear
waste within their borders. A Washington State law with overwhelming
public support was successfully challenged by the Department of
Energy. The court
found it to violate the Atomic Energy act and the commerce
clause of the US Constitution. Some local governments are starting
to protest that there is no requirement for the NRC to review
emergency and evacuation plants once a plant is licensed. Even
if the population and traffic patters change significantly in
the vicinity of a plant, the plant owner is not required to submit,
and the NRC is not required to review updated plans. Pilgrim
in Massachusetts and Three
Mile Island in Pennsylvania are among the locations where
local governments are protesting. In early May, workers were contaminated
during an accident at Prairie
Island in Wisconsin.
There is an interesting trend on the Reuters
wire service. They have been reporting every instance of a nuclear
plant falling below 100% output, as well as all planned and unplanned
outages. We have been collecting these reports on our Nuclear
Power Plants page. They demonstrate beyond doubt that nuclear
power does not operate 24/7, and that in fact some plants operate
at consistently reduced efficiency, such as the 19
outages experienced by Palo Verde since February 2004, at
increased cost to their ratepayers. At Three Mile Island in late
May, a control room worker failed to notice the presence of an
inspector, because he was too engrossed in his video
game. A damning
report released in late June by the Government Accountability
Office noted problems with the " safety culture" of
the nuclear industry, including the NRC, and calls its oversight
of nuclear power plants " ineffective." There have been
siren
failures, more radioactive waterleaks,
radioactive parts have gone
missing,
April 2006 - update
Grassroots and Local Legislative
Resistance to the Nuclear Power Industry
There have been recent local victories. In Illinois,
the senate has passed
a bill requiring disclosure of all radioactive releases, at
levels beyond those required by the NRC. Organizations like the
Connecticut
Coalition Against Millstone, the Duxbury
Nuclear Advisory Committee (Ma) and the New
England Coalition (VT) are garnering more media time, states
like Illinois,
New
Jersey and Vermont
are imposing state regulations on power plants, and state legislative
candidates like Susan
Zimet in New York are running on platforms to shut down nuclear
power plants.
Power Plant Safety Issues
On March 2, the operators of Vermont Yankee
received
approval to raise the power output by 20 percent, in 5 percent
increments. After raising the output on March 4, vibrations
were detected, and output was frozen until the source of the
problem was found and fixed. The problem was found to be the steam
dryer, the very part of the plant machinery that activists had
protested could not withstand the higher power production. The
safety sirens at Indian Point in Westchester County, NY failed
again in a test. This followed an incident where a contractor
hit a power switch that cut
off power to the reactor control rods. The warning sirens
at North Anna in Virginia also failed
this month. There have been several other incidences of radioactive
leaks from power plants, usually of Tritium, but there has been
one instance of Strontium-90, at levels three
times higher than federally allowed levels. On March 31, the
operators noted that a
hole had been " drilled" into a pipe that is part
of a system that helps maintain pressure.
March 2006 - update
Global Nuclear Energy Partnership
The partnership
with Russia to control the production and disposition of nuclear
fuel and waste, forged in January has been expanded to include
a select list of other nations. This policy defies the authority
of the IAEA, and has foreign policy implications, especially regarding
Iran,
India
and Ukraine.
Grassroots Resistance to the Nuclear
Power Industry
There have been recent local victories. In
Illinois, Senator Barak Obama is proposing
legislation that would require nuclear power plant operators
to notify local authorities of unintentional leaks of radioactive
materials. In New Jersey, the NRC was pressured into hearing the
testimony of a group of activists concerned about the corrosion
on a steel radiation barrier. These
activists may be the first group allowed this kind of hearing
at the NRC . County officials in New
York are demanding answers from Entergy about leaks and health
risks. In Vermont, the New England Coalition is the only
citizens group to achieve intervenor status before the NRC on
a power uprate.
Power Plant Safety Issues
Plumes of radioactive
water have been found near Palo Verde in Arizona. Indian
Point 2 had to be shut down suddenly. There was a fire
at the Byron Nuclear Generating Station in Illinois. An
emergency was declared at the LaSalle County nuclear plant.
In New Jersey there are fears that the radiation barrier in the
reactor vessel at Oyster Creek has nearly
corroded through. There have also been investigations at Turkey
Point and Three
Mile Island into security lapses. Both plants contract for
security services with Wackenhut.
Alternatives
to Nuclear Power Plants
More information coming soon
More information coming soon
More information coming soon
Visit
Our Chernobyl Page
More information coming soon
Special
Reports
- "Against
the Grain," KPFA Free Speech Radio, 09/12/2006 - Tyson
Slocum, of "Public Citizen" in D.C., explains that
there's no energy crisis, only artificial energy shortages,
a form of supply manipulation, created by taking power plants
offline "for maintenance," but really just to drive
up prices.
- Walking
a Nuclear Tightrope: Unlearned Lessons of Year-plus Reactor
Outages a report of the Union of Concerned Scientists
- The
Future of Nuclear Power: An Interdisciplinary MIT Study
(2003)
- Greenpeace
Announces Alternative to Government Energy Review 2006(UK)
- Executive
Summary of the Energy Policy of 2005 (Please refer to note
at the top of the article)
- Fact
Sheet - Is Nuclear Power Clean? Is Nuclear Power Safe?
- Renewable
Energy -- Mitigating Global Warming a report of the Union
of Concerned Scientists
- Real
Energy Solutions: The Renewable Electricity Standard a report
of the Union of Concerned Scientists
- Nuclear
Power: No solution to Climate Change, a report of the Nuclear
Information and Resource Service
- Nuclear
Power Plant Safety, a video by the Nuclear Information and
Information Service (Please scroll down to the
"Security Video" and select the appropriate viewer)
- Nuclear
Power Plant Safety, a report by the Union of Concerned Scientists.
- Nuclear
plant fiascoes likely with age, secret study suggests
- The Globalization
of the Nuclear Power Industry
- Skull
Valley: Radioactive Waste and the American West
- Nuclear
murder - Americas Atomic War Against Its Citizens
and Why Its Not Over Yet - Boise Weekly
- Fallout
San Francisco Weekly
- Toxic Utah: Paying
the price
- Poisoned
workers and communities USA Today
- Clearing
the Lines: Want an Energy Secretary? Take your pick! (Four Part
Series) - by Stephen Heiser
- Rocky Flats From Cold Wars
to Hot Prosperity Part1
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4
- Cold War Poison: The
Paducah Legacy - Louisville Courier-Journal
- Fission on
the Brink - South Bend Tribune
- Tokai Nuclear
Gamble (Multi Media)
- Paducah
Gaseous Diffusion Plant
- Special
report: Deadly Alliance
- Radioactive
roulette - Bergen Record
-
Three Mile Island: What Happened
- A
Journey Through the Nuclear Age
- World
Nuclear Status Associated Pres
- Nuclear Legacy Geographic
Classification
Nuclear Database / Tables